Status
Not open for further replies.

Hans

New member
Joined
Dec 30, 2010
Messages
9
Reason
Learn about ALS
Country
NL
State
Noord Holland
City
amsterdam
Hello everybody,

I guess I am not the only one here worrying about having MND (in my case: PMSA). I am frightened, spent much time thinking up worst case scenario’s. Need tranquilizers now and then to fence off the worst fears. Hope some of you find the time to read my (case)story below and possible give some advice/answers to the questions that I have (below). Before you read on, basic stuff that you might want to now: I am 46 years old, married, daughter (12). Normally in good physical shape (running, bike), but with a history of bi-polaire depression II (the mild version) and anxietyproblems linked to hypochondria.

My case:

The problems started in october. First pain in my lower back in the morning and also pain a certain spot in the middle of the spine and a weird feeling at several place in my back and arms, as if someone put a small needle in there. I also experienced moments (hours) of extreme cold. These things annoyed me, but I didn't pay too much attention. Then I found myself having a problem urinating. That is, I had to go the bathroom constantly (as much as 10 times in the morning only, as to before maybe 4 times a day). At the same time I experienced a strange feeling in my underbelly, as if muscles there were constantly twitching. Also: a feeling of fatigue in my legs.

After four weeks I went to my doctor who sent me to a neurologist with the suggestion: ‘myopathie/neuropathie?’

By the time (waiting list) of the appointment (mid november) I already had a new thing: fasciculations in my legs (both sides, upper and lower). This is when I started worrying, went on the internet and found out about ALS.

By this time I got extremely worried, spent large parts of my day surfing the web looking for clues. I wondered if my left leg hadn’t lost volume (comparing the legs, not being sure; maybe the left leg had always been somewhat less voluminous?).

The neurologist then did what I assume is the standard neurological exam. He tested my strength, reflexes, coordination and concluded that everything was normal (no symptoms also that suggest central motor neuron problems). He then ordered my blood tested (no idea what he tested) and an MRI for the painfull spot along my spine. Again the results were ok. An EMG was ordered, to be sure.

Since then fasciculations continued in legs, feet and occasionally also in arms and back and also under my eye and in the mouse of my hands. Also when I walked I noticed that my left foot didn’t behave normally, as if it forgot how to put itself down (but I put this down to being conscious of my walking and therefore intervening with an otherwise automatic process and in doing so onbstructing this proces). Also, when running (my condition didn’t detoriate) I experienced extraordinary fatigue in my shoulders and a feeling as if my throat ‘closed itself’ at the peak of my running (I suppose it could be called a somewhat asthmatic feeling) and also I started waking up as if something got stuck in my throat, during daytime I had to keep swallowing.

Mid december the weakness in my legs had dissapeared (thanks to intense exercise?; I started running four times a week) as had the ‘not being able to walk automatically’-sensation in my left foot’, but fasciculations and throat ‘problems’ continued and now I also noticed that my hands had started trembling (for instance holding a book, reading it) and it appeared that my left hand didn’t behave normally, as if the pink now had it’s own thoughts about what to do (typing lost it’s ‘automatic’ feel,; again: because I start paying attention). No loss of strength was noticible however, so again, as with the ‘walking problem’ I tried to convince myself that by concentrating on the hand I created the sensation of the left hand behaving strangely (for instance: typing).

15 december I had the EMG, in my legs and right arm. The results were clean said the neuro. A fasciculation in my lower leg was observed, but no worrysome clues. He looked at the trembling of my hands and said that it looked like a somewhat heightened tonus. When I told him of the sensations in my throat he didn’t inspect the throat, but said that could be well explained by the fact that in the past I had my bouts with hypochondria (this in the meantime I had confessed to him). No more exams were ordered and of I went. If an EMG is clean, he told me, there is no ALS/PMSA, and that’s it. It’s all in your mind he said (apart form the benign fasciculations)

Now two weeks later. Fasciculations still the same, as is the trembling of my hands (sign of weakness?). The throat problem has become much worse. I experience the feeling that sometimes food is left in my throat after a meal, I sometime have a burning sensation in my mouth (and tongue), the mouth is extremely dry, my voice now and then somewhat hoarsely and when I exercise it is as if my throat closes and I have problems getting the air in. Also now and then I notice that it is as if formulating words is bothersome, as if I have to do an extra effort (again, again; because I now this to be a symptom and therefore start experiencing it?).

All this leaves me with questions. Summed up:

1) Can symptoms of MND develop in such a short time (three months now), and in so many different areas (hand, leg, throat, tongue)?
2) Is it possible that the initial weakness in my legs was a first sign but is now gone only because of exercise?
3) About the EMG; is it possible to have clean EMG and have ALS/PMSA at a stage when fasciculations are already measurable and were observed during the EMG? And now that I experience bulbair symptoms, is it necessary to have a second EMG, just to be sure?
4) How probable is it that all of these sensations (apart from the fasciculations) have their root in anxiety and knowledge about MND symptoms? That they are somehow all stress induced? How can I be sure?
5) Should I check a doctor specialized in the throat/tongue area? Should I insist on a second EMG or is this first EMG a definitive ‘no MND’?
 
Hi Hans in answer to your questions
1) no, they start in one are, start with weakness, that is profound, eg foot drop, unable to open a door. It does not come on suddenl in many areas at once.

2) The weakness is caused by irreparable damage, it cannot be exercised away.

3) open for endless debate, but no you will never be given a diagnosed with a clean emg.

4&5)definitely could be caused bY anxiety , but you can never be absolutely sure until you have been checked by a Dr. If you are concerned, no harm can come from seeing an net specialist.

Hope this helps
Aly
 
Thanks, is somewhat reassuring. So much to read here about clean EMG's and still having MND, it scares me, since my EMG was done only in legs and one arm (not the side moste effected, not inthe bulbar region).
 
You can't have a clean EMG and have ALS. Where did you get that from?
 
Hans, be careful of the debate, for what it's worth. It is not about Having ALS with a clean EMG. It's absolutely impossible to have ALS with a clean emg as you need lower motor neuron signs for that diagnosis. You will not have Lmn signs with a clean EMG.
The endless debate is more about thing changing many years down the track after a clean EMG.

One way of looking at it is this.....
You have an Mri scan of your abdo to rule out Cancer after pain. The results are normal... 5 years later you get pain again and an MRI shows you have bowel cancer. Does this mean you had cancer before or that the 2 incidents are connected. Of course not.

Aly
 
Here's another analogy:

Many things can cause a person to start sneezing and coughing. It could be due to a virus. The doc does the testing to check for viral infections and the test comes back negative.

He asks more questions and finds you recently became a dog owner. The sneezing and dog ownership happen to come about at the same time. He tests you for allergies and bingo! You either have to get rid of Snoopy or take medication for as long as you own him.

If your symptoms are being caused by ALS, the EMG would pick up the abnormalities in the lower motor neuron signals that are caused by ALS. If those abnormalities do not appear on the EMG, the cause of your symptoms cannot be attributed to ALS.
 
Last edited:
I really want to believe this, reassuring as it is. But I keep wondering about these stories (also to be found on this forum) from people having clean EMG's although at the time of EMG they already had symptoms of MND. I still wonder if it could be that lower motor neuron disease is not picked up in EMG when the EMG is not done in the most affected areas, or when it's done in the early beginning of the disease.
 
You are not listening. A clean EMG mean no ALS period. You must be looking in the Is this ALS? Do I have ALS? section. There is so much misinformation there from people who think they have ALS.
 
I really want to believe this, reassuring as it is. But I keep wondering about these stories (also to be found on this forum) from people having clean EMG's although at the time of EMG they already had symptoms of MND. I still wonder if it could be that lower motor neuron disease is not picked up in EMG when the EMG is not done in the most affected areas, or when it's done in the early beginning of the disease.

Actually, you don't really want to believe it, because if you really wanted to believe it, you would simply believe it and not be troubled further with it. Just as you chose to believe what you read on the Internet over what your doctors have told you. Apparently, their answer for your problems was less appealing to you than the fear, the obsessive self-examination, and the frenzied searching for support from the posts of people who are/were as fearful, obsessed and confused as you are. Quite frankly, it looks like you would rather be miserable than relieved, and prefer to believe hearsay and gossip to seeking out truth. To each his own, I guess.

Do yourself a favor and ignore any posts here about EMGs that were not written by the user named "wright". wright is a professor at a medical school, he teaches medical students how to do EMGs on patients, and he will give you accurate information about how the test is done and what the results mean.

Good luck to you.
 
hans . . Between aly ,joel ,tryfogey and zaphoon you have just received advice from some of the most knowledgeable people on this forum . . Listen to what they saying . . I feel for you anxiety but take in what they have said . . And try to calm and relax . . Good luck and god bless . . . Alex
 
Ok, thanks everybody, all the best

Hans
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top